Pro Pac Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo: Pros, Cons, and What to Xaiv

Cov txheej txheem:

Pro Pac Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo: Pros, Cons, and What to Xaiv
Pro Pac Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo: Pros, Cons, and What to Xaiv
Anonim

Xaiv zaub mov zoo rau koj tus hlub tus khub yuav mob taub hau tiag tiag! Qhov tseeb, nws yog ib txwm xav tias muaj kev ntxhov siab me ntsis los ntawm ntau txoj kev xaiv muaj nyob hauv khw muag khoom noj dev. Yuav ua li cas koj xaiv cov zaub mov zoo raws li qhov xav tau ntawm koj tus dev? Puas tsim nyog muab pov tseg ntau dua rau lub npe hwm?

Txhawm rau pab koj hauv koj qhov kev tshawb nrhiav, peb muab ob hom khoom noj dev zoo tshaj plaws uas ob leeg cog lus tias muaj txiaj ntsig kev noj qab haus huv rau koj tus menyuam: Pro Pac thiab Blue Buffalo. Mus nyeem ntawv kom paub tus yeej ntawm kev sib ntaus sib tua!

Sneak Peek ntawm tus yeej: Pro Pac Dog Food

Pro Pac thiab Blue Buffalo yog cov khoom lag luam zoo uas tau ua pov thawj lawv tus kheej hauv khw muag khoom noj dev. Raws li lawv cov khoom xyaw ib leeg, cov khoom noj dev no zoo li cov khoom qhuav qhuav. Txawm li cas los xij, thaum cov khoom noj no muaj ntau yam sib xws, peb nyiam Pro Pac rau tag nrho cov khoom xyaw zoo thiab tus nqi pheej yig dua. Tsis tas li ntawd, nws cov keeb kwm rov qab zoo dua li Blue Buffalo.

Nyob ib pliag

Duab
Duab

Pro Pac

  • 3,570 kcal/kg
  • 24% protein
  • 14% rog
  • Grain-free
  • Nqaij qaib yog thawj cov khoom xyaw
  • Muaj ntau cov txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub zoo

Blue Buffalo

  • 3,618 kcal/kg
  • 24% protein
  • 14% rog
  • Deboned qaib is the first ingredient
  • Muaj kev noj qab nyob zoo ntawm cov nplej

About Pro Pac

Pro Pac yog ib lub lag luam me me, tsev neeg Asmeskas muaj los ntawm Midwestern Pet Foods, Inc. Nws tsim cov qauv sib npaug rau txhua theem ntawm tus tsiaj lub neej, thiab tag nrho cov zaub mov noj dev thiab miv yog tsim los ntawm cov chaw hauv plaub. cov nroog thoob plaws tebchaws Meskas.

Lub tuam txhab lub hom phiaj ntawm tus kheej yog tsim cov khoom noj tsiaj zoo tshaj plaws, thiab nws tau ua txij li xyoo 1926. Koj tuaj yeem yuav nws cov khoom hauv online thiab hauv ntau lub khw muag tsiaj thoob plaws Tebchaws Meskas.

Pro Pac Ultimates yog qhov zoo tagnrho rau cov dev nrog plab rhiab heev

Pro Pac paub, ntawm lwm yam, rau nws cov kab ntawm Ultimates cov khoom, uas yog formulated tsis muaj pob kws, nplej, los yog soy, uas tej zaum yuav ua pov thawj zoo rau dev nrog cov khoom rhiab heev.

Daim ntawv qhia muaj cov tshuaj tiv thaiv antioxidant

Antioxidants yog cov as-ham tseem ceeb uas pab cuam tshuam thiab txwv tsis pub muaj cov dawb radicals ntawm cov hlwb. Yeej, lawv pab tswj koj tus dev kev noj qab haus huv tag nrho los ntawm kev ua kom qeeb ntawm lawv cov hlwb. Antioxidants yuav pab tau rau:

  • Txhawb kev paub txog kev noj qab haus huv hauv cov dev laus
  • Txhim kho lub cev tiv thaiv kab mob
  • Txo cov tsos mob ntawm o

Pro Pac dog food muaj antioxidants xws li vitamins A thiab C, uas yog los ntawm txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub xws li blueberries, carrots, thiab spinach. Cov fibers hauv cov khoom xyaw no kuj pab hauv kev zom zaub mov.

Duab
Duab

Nqaij Nplej (Nqaij, Lamb, Nqaij nyuj) Yog thawj cov khoom xyaw

Tej pluas mov feem ntau muaj lub koob npe phem hauv cov khoom noj tsiaj. Txawm li cas los xij, raws li Ohio University Veterinary Medical Center, nqaij qaib noj muaj protein ntau dua li nqaij qaib tshiab. Qhov tseeb, tag nrho cov nqaij noj mov yog qhov muaj zog ntawm cov protein ntau vim tias cov dej tau raug tshem tawm, uas ua rau muaj kev sib koom ua ke zoo dua hauv cov khoom noj qhuav. Yog li ntawd, nqaij qaib noj tuaj yeem yog qhov zoo ntawm cov protein ntau ntawm tus nqi qis.

Pro Pac Nyuaj Siab

Pro Pac nyiam nyob rau hauv tus nqi siab, tab sis nws tsis kim li ntau lwm yam khoom noj dev hwm.

Pros

  • Cov khoom xyaw zoo yog txhua qhov chaw nyob hauv Asmeskas
  • Muaj cov antioxidants thiab fiber ntau rau kev noj qab haus huv zoo dua
  • Tsis suav pob kws, nplej, los yog soy

Cons

Pricey

About Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo yog lub npe hu ua Blue, Airedale aub ntawm tus tsim Jackie thiab Bill Npis Sov. Qhov tseeb, thaum lawv tus aub uas lawv hlub tau tsim teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv, ob tug kwv tij tau pib nyiam noj zaub mov los txhim kho kev noj qab haus huv ntawm cov tsiaj, nrog rau lub hom phiaj txhawb kev tiv thaiv kab mob ntawm peb cov phooj ywg plaub-legged.

Blue Buffalo Creates Recipes Tailored to Specific Dietary Needs

Muaj ntau hom qauv hloov kho raws li cov kev xav tau ntawm cov dev, suav nrog cov neeg uas raug kev txom nyem los ntawm daim tawv nqaij, lub cev tsis muaj zog, teeb meem sib koom tes, lossis tswj qhov hnyav.

It Recipes Don't contain "Controversial" Ingredients

Blue Buffalo Dog Food tsis muaj pob kws, hom qoob mog, xim xim, tsw, khoom noj khoom haus, lossis cov khoom lag luam. Tsis tas li ntawd, lub tuam txhab muab ob hom qoob loo tsis pub mis. Txawm li cas los xij, "tsis muaj nplej" lossis tsis muaj "cov khoom lag luam" tsis tas yuav lav cov khoom noj khoom haus zoo, vim tias cov khoom xyaw "tsis sib haum xeeb" tsis tas yuav ua phem rau dev. Txawm li cas los xij, ntau tus tswv tsiaj feem ntau npaj them tus nqi siab rau cov khoom noj no.

Duab
Duab

Tseem kim, Txawm yog High-End Dog Food

Txawm hais tias qhov zoo ntawm cov khoom xyaw thiab kev saib xyuas hauv kev tsim Blue Buffalo Dog Food's zaub mov txawv, peb tsis ntseeg tias nws tus nqi siab yog qhov ncaj ncees. Tseeb tiag, siv "cov nqaij qaib tiag tiag" thiab zam cov khoom xyaw xws li cov nplej tsis tas yuav cuam tshuam nrog kev noj zaub mov zoo thiab noj qab haus huv.

Blue Buffalo Tau iab liam tshaj tawm nws cov khoom cuav

Nyob rau xyoo 2020, Blue Buffalo Dog Food raug foob vim tsim cov ntawv tshaj tawm cuav rau nws cov kab Blue Wilderness zaub mov dev. Cov phiaj xwm kev lag luam nthuav tawm cov lus hais tias nws cov khoom noj dev yog cov protein ntau thiab yog li ntawd, zoo ib yam li kev noj zaub mov ntawm hma qus. Txawm li cas los xij, cov lus thov no yog kev dag ntxias, vim Blue Wilderness cov khoom lag luam kuj muaj "cov carbohydrates ntau dua li cov hma grey hma yuav noj tau hauv nws lub neej."

Pros

  • Cov zaub mov ua tiav tsawg kawg tau yoog raws cov kev xav tau tshwj xeeb
  • Txhua yam zaub mov muaj "LifeSource Bits" muab los ntawm txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub
  • Tsis suav nrog pob kws, nplej, taum, lossis cov khoom lag luam

Cons

  • Nyob zoo rau yam koj tau txais
  • Kev liam ntawm kev tshaj tawm cuav

3 Nrov Tshaj Plaws Pro Pac Dog Food Recipes

Cia peb saib peb ntawm cov zaub mov nrov tshaj plaws los ntawm Pro Pac.

1. Ultimates Nqaij qaib & Nplej Loj Cov Neeg Laus Noj Zaub Mov

Duab
Duab

Ultimates Chicken Meal & Brown Rice yog tsim los rau cov kev xav tau tshwj xeeb ntawm cov dev loj. Qhov sib ntxiv ntawm glucosamine thiab chondroitin sulfate pab ua kom koj tus dev loj pob qij txha noj qab nyob zoo. Cov mis no tseem muaj cov tshuaj antioxidants thiab cov vitamins los txhawb kev tiv thaiv kab mob thiab pab zom zaub mov. Txawm li cas los xij, thawj cov khoom xyaw yog nqaij qaib thiab tsis yog nqaij qaib tiag tiag, thiab qee tus tswv tsev tsuas yog xav muab cov nqaij "tseem" rau lawv cov tsiaj. Tsis tas li ntawd, cov khoom noj no yog kim heev, tab sis tsis kim li lwm yam khoom lag luam zoo sib xws.

Pros

  • Tshuaj nyob rau hauv Teb Chaws Asmeskas
  • No ntxiv pob kws, nplej, los yog soy
  • Formula ntim nrog antioxidants thiab fiber
  • Enriched nrog glucosamine thiab chondroitin sulfate rau kev sib koom noj qab haus huv nyob rau hauv loj dev breeds

Cons

  • Nqaij qaib yog thawj cov khoom siv tsis yog nqaij qaib tiag tiag
  • Keem tab sis tseem pheej yig dua ntau lwm hom khoom zoo ib yam

2. Pro Pac Ultimates Overland Grain-Free Red Beef & Qos

Duab
Duab

Pro Pac Ultimates Overland Red Beef yog cov mis tsis muaj nplej nrog qos yaj ywm, uas feem ntau tsis muaj teeb meem rau cov dev feem ntau. Txawm li cas los xij, qhov no tuaj yeem ua rau muaj teeb meem hauv plab hnyuv (gas, tsam plab) hauv qee tus dev rhiab heev. Txawm li cas los xij, daim ntawv qhia no gluten-dawb, ntim nrog cov antioxidants thiab fiber ntau thiab ntxiv taurine los tiv thaiv lub plawv, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog nrov nrog cov dev uas zoo li nyiam qhov kev ntxhib los mos ntawm kibble.

Pros

  • Ntau fiber ntau
  • Grain-free
  • Ntxiv taurine rau lub plawv noj qab haus huv
  • Ntau tus dev zoo li txaus siab rau qhov kev ntxhib los mos

Cons

  • Nqaij nyuj ua thawj cov khoom xyaw
  • qos yaj ywm yuav nyuaj rau qee tus dev zom

3. Pro Pac Ultimates Bayside Xaiv Ntses & Qos Tsis Pub

Duab
Duab

Pro Pac Ultimates Bayside Xaiv Ntses & Qos yaj ywm yog cov mis tsis muaj nplej ua nrog cov ntses dawb. Cov ntsiab lus fiber ntau kuj tsawg, tab sis muaj ntau cov omega-6 thiab -3 fatty acids, uas pab lub plawv, ntsws, hlab ntsha, thiab lub cev tsis muaj zog ua haujlwm raws li lawv yuav tsum tau.

Pros

  • Suited for all life stages
  • Grain-free
  • Zoo tso siab los ntawm dev nrog plab rhiab

Cons

  • Tsis muaj fiber ntau los pab digestion
  • Qee tus neeg noj zaub mov tsis nyiam ntses ntses

3 Nrov Nrov Tshaj Plaws Blue Buffalo Dog Food Recipes

1. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Nature's Evolutionary Diet

Duab
Duab

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Nature's Scalable Diet is a high-protein formula (34%), which is about 10% more than other products in this review. Nws kuj muaj 15% rog thiab 6% fiber ntau, yog li koj tus dev nquag yuav hnov qab ntev dua ntawm cov zaub mov. Cov zaub mov no muaj cov carbohydrates nyuaj xws li oats thiab barley ua lub zog zoo. Tab sis yog tias koj tus dev yog ntau hom tub nkeeg, saib cov ntu uas koj muab rau lawv kom tsis txhob hnyav nce.

Tsis muaj khoom qab zib, los ntawm cov khoom lag luam, thiab ntxiv cov khoom khaws cia. Blue Buffalo kuj scrupulously zam tsis ntxiv kua, nplej, los yog pob kws rau nws cov zaub mov. Thaum kawg, Blue Wilderness kab ntawm cov zaub mov muaj "LifeSource Bits," tshwj xeeb sib xyaw ntawm antioxidants, vitamins, thiab minerals uas txhawb kev tiv thaiv kab mob thiab noj qab haus huv oxidative tshuav nyiaj li cas.

Txawm li cas los xij, qhov teeb meem loj ntawm Blue Buffalo (thiab qhov no mus rau nws cov khoom lag luam tag nrho, tsis yog Wilderness nkaus xwb) yog lub tuam txhab muaj keeb kwm ntev ntawm kev rov qab los.

Pros

  • Includes oats thiab barley as complex carbohydrate sources
  • Muab lub zog thiab lub zog rau cov dev nquag
  • High protein cov ntsiab lus
  • Omega-3 thiab -6 fatty acids los txhawb lub tsho zoo nkauj

Cons

  • Ntau tus nco qab hauv keeb kwm hom
  • Tej zaum yuav ua rau qhov hnyav nce hauv cov dev tsis muaj zog

2. Blue Buffalo Life Protection Adult Chicken & Brown Rice

Duab
Duab

Blue Buffalo Life Protection is a plant-based dry dog foods siv cov nqaij nruab nrab ntawm cov nqaij noj ua thawj qhov chaw ntawm cov tsiaj protein. Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Adult Chicken & Brown Rice daim ntawv qhia siv cov nqaij qaib uas yog thawj cov khoom xyaw, tab sis nws kuj muaj qee qhov muaj peev xwm ua xua, xws li qe qhuav thiab cov txiv lws suav qhuav. Nutritionally, cov khoom no muaj ib tug dlej npaum li cas ntawm cov protein thiab carbohydrates, ua rau nws yog ib qho khoom noj zoo rau cov dev uas tsis muaj zog. Cov khoom xyaw kuj muaj xws li txiv hmab txiv ntoo (cranberries, blueberries) thiab zaub (qos qos yaj ywm, spinach, carrots) ntxiv rau cov vitamins thiab minerals.

Zuag qhia tag nrho, nws yog ib qho khoom noj zoo uas cov dev feem ntau yuav nyiam, tab sis peb xav tias nws nyob ntawm tus nqi pheej yig xav txog nws cov khoom noj khoom haus nruab nrab.

Pros

  • Suited for all life stages
  • High protein cov ntsiab lus
  • Cov khoom xyaw yog USDA tshuaj xyuas
  • All-natural ingredients with no artificial additives

Cons

  • Muaj qee yam tshuaj tsis haum
  • muaj ntau cov zaub mov muaj protein ntau
  • Pricey

3. Blue Buffalo Freedom Adult He althy Weight Chicken Recipe

Duab
Duab

Blue Buffalo Freedom khoom noj dev qhuav yog tsim los pab cov neeg laus noj qab haus huv qhov hnyav nrog cov protein zoo thiab cov ntsiab lus muaj roj tsawg. Cov kib no yog tsim los ntawm cov nqaij qaib tiag tiag, thiab tsis muaj pob kws, nplej, taum pauv, khoom qab zib, thiab cov khoom noj khoom haus, uas yuav tsum txaus siab rau cov neeg noj mov. Cov mis no kuj suav nrog cov tshuaj antioxidants, cov zaub mov, thiab cov vitamins nyob rau hauv daim ntawv ntawm LifeSource Bits tshwj xeeb rau Blue Buffalo. Txawm li cas los xij, cov khoom noj no muaj cov hmoov txhuv nplej siab carbohydrates thiab kim.

Pros

  • Tsis muaj pob kws, nplej, taum pauv, khoom qab zib, lossis cov khoom khaws cia
  • Cov protein zoo thiab muaj roj tsawg
  • Muaj qaib tiag tiag
  • Zoo siab txais tos los ntawm cov dev nrog lub plab rhiab

Cons

  • Nyob zoo
  • Ntau cov hmoov txhuv nplej siab carbs

Recall History of Pro Pac thiab Blue Buffalo

Pro Pac tau khaws cov ntaub ntawv zoo meej tsis rov qab mus txog thaum nyuam qhuav dhau los. Thaum Lub Ib Hlis 11, 2021, Midwestern Pet Foods tau tshaj tawm qhov kev rov qab los ntawm cov npe loj uas nws ua haujlwm rau aflatoxin, uas yog pwm los ntawm cov khoom uas tuaj yeem ua rau muaj kev phom sij thiab ua rau tuag taus rau cov tsiaj kom txaus.

Ob daim Pro Pac zaub mov txawv tau cuam tshuam los ntawm qhov rov qab:

  • Pro Pac Adult Mini Chunk, 40 lb. bag
  • Pro Pac Performance Puppy, 40 lb. bag

Thaum Lub Peb Hlis 27, 2021, Midwestern Pet Foods tau tshaj tawm qhov kev yeem rov qab los rau ntau ntawm nws cov khoom kab, suav nrog Pro Pac Ultimates kab. Qhov kev rov qab los no yog vim muaj peev xwm kis tau tus kab mob salmonella, uas yog ib qho ntawm feem ntau ua rau cov khoom noj tsiaj rov qab hauv Tebchaws Meskas.

Txawm li cas los xij, Blue Buffalo cov npe ntawm cov khoom noj dev rov qab muaj ntau dua. Cov kev nco qab no suav nrog cov xwm txheej ntau xyoo, suav nrog:

2010

Rov qab los ntawm ntau yam khoom rau ntau ntau cov vitamin D, suav nrog

  • Blue Wilderness Chicken Flavor
  • Blue Life Protection Formula Natural Chicken
  • Blue Basics Limited Ingredient Formula
  • Salmon and Brown Rice Loj Breed Adult

2015

Tom tau rov qab los ntawm Cub Size Wilderness Wilder Chew Bones dog zaub mov vim muaj kab mob salmonella.

2016

Tseem tau rov qab los ntawm Kev Tiv Thaiv Lub Neej Cov Qauv Ntses thiab Qos Qab Zib Daim Ntawv Qhia rau pwm kab mob.

2017

Muaj kev rov qab los ntawm ntau yam khoom, suav nrog

  • Homestyle Recipe Noj qab nyob zoo yuag (tseem muaj hlau kis tau)
  • Blue Divine Delights thiab Blue Wilderness Trail (cov teeb meem kev ncaj ncees nrog cov ntawv nplaum rau ntawm khob)
  • Rocky Mountain Recipe TM Red Meat Dinner Wet Food Rau Cov Neeg Laus (nce nqaij nyug thyroid ntau ntau)

Pro Pac vs Blue Buffalo Sib piv

Peb piv Pro Pac rau Blue Buffalo nyob rau hauv ob peb pawg tseem ceeb, saib seb ntawm ob hom yuav sawv tawm.

Taste

Winner: Blue Buffalo

Feem ntau, cov dev zoo li nyiam qhov saj thiab kev ntxhib los mos ntawm Blue Buffalo ntau dua, tej zaum vim tias "cov nqaij tiag" yog ib qho ntawm thawj cov khoom xyaw. Tseem, nws feem ntau nyob ntawm qhov nyiam ntawm txhua tus dev.

Nutritional Value

Winner: Tie

Ntawm cov khoom noj khoom haus, kev sib ntaus sib tua yog nruj vim tias ob lub npe muaj qhov tseem ceeb tib yam kev tshuaj ntsuam xyuas, nrog tsuas yog 1% ntau cov protein thiab roj crude rau Blue Buffalo.

Price

Winner: Pro Pac

Pro Pac yeej ntawm no vim tias nws tus nqi, txawm tias siab, yog qhov ncaj ncees thiab pheej yig dua li Blue Buffalo.

Selection

Winner: Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo yeej nyob rau hauv pawg no vim tias nws muaj ntau yam khoom sib txawv raws li cov kev xav tau tshwj xeeb ntawm cov dev.

Txhua

Winner: Pro Pac

Vim nws qhov keeb kwm rov qab tsis zoo, tus nqi pheej yig, cov khoom xyaw zoo, thiab tsis muaj cov lus tsis tseeb tshaj tawm, peb xaiv Pro Pac ua tus yeej meej hauv qhov kev sib ntaus sib tua kub no.

Duab
Duab

Conclusion

Pro Pac thiab Blue Buffalo yog ob hom khoom noj dev saum toj no. Lawv ob leeg muab cov zaub mov ua hauv cov chaw hauv Tebchaws Meskas thiab tsis ntxiv pob kws, kua, lossis nplej. Lawv cov qauv yog loaded nrog antioxidants, vitamins, thiab minerals, tab sis Blue Buffalo feem ntau siv cov nqaij tiag tiag ua thawj cov khoom xyaw thiab Pro Pac siv cov nqaij noj.

Qhov tau hais tias, peb suav tias Pro Pac yog qhov kev xaiv zoo dua, tsis yog vim nws tus nqi xwb tab sis kuj tseem muaj keeb kwm kev nyab xeeb thiab ua kom pob tshab nrog nws cov neeg siv khoom.

Pom zoo: