Thaum koj ntsib kev xaiv ntawm ob hom khoom noj dev uas muaj kev ntseeg siab nrog kev ntaus nqi zoo, nws tuaj yeem ua rau me ntsis bewildering. Fromm thiab Acana ob leeg tsim cov khoom noj dev zoo thiab muaj lub koob npe nrov hauv khw muag khoom noj dev, tab sis puas muaj ib qho me ntsis ntawm lwm qhov?
Nyob rau hauv tsab xov xwm no, peb yuav qhia rau koj txog dab tsi ob lub npe no hais txog, lawv keeb kwm, yam lawv muaj, thiab qhov zoo thiab qhov tsis zoo ntawm txhua tus los pab koj txiav txim siab seb qhov twg yuav zoo tshaj rau koj. dog.
A Sneak Peek ntawm tus yeej: Acana
Nws tsis yog qhov kev txiav txim siab yooj yim, tab sis peb tau xaiv Acana ua peb tus yeej ntawm lub sijhawm no. Ob lub npe muaj ntau yam los muab, tab sis qhov peb nyiam tshaj plaws txog Acana yog nws muaj nyob rau ntawm ntau qhov chaw muag khoom hauv online, nws tseem ceeb heev rau kev tsim cov khoom noj muaj protein ntau nrog cov khoom xyaw ntuj, thiab nws tsis muaj keeb kwm rov qab los.
Ob tug ntawm Acana cov neeg muag khoom zoo tshaj plaws yog Daim Ntawv Qhia Nqaij Liab thiab Daim Ntawv Qhia Cov Ntses Dej. Ob leeg yog tsim los ntawm 60% tsiaj cov khoom xyaw, 40% txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub, thiab muaj protein ntau. Lawv kuj pub dawb los ntawm cov khoom xyaw hluavtaws, nplej, tapioca, pob kws, thiab soy.
About Fromm
Raws nyob rau hauv Wisconsin, Fromm Family Foods yog tsev neeg thiab tsev neeg cov khoom noj tsiaj ua lag luam rov qab mus rau xyoo 1904, txawm tias lawv tsev neeg thiab kev lag luam kev sib raug zoo rov qab mus rau xyoo 19th. Los ntawm nruab nrab xyoo pua nees nkaum, Fromm tau pib tsim qhov lawv hu ua "premium" kibble ua los ntawm kev sib xyaw ntawm cov nqaij siav thiab nplej.
Hnub no, lub tuam txhab tseem vam meej. Fromm txaus siab rau kev tsim cov khoom noj tsiaj uas tsim los ntawm cov protein zoo thiab cov khoom xyaw thiab ua kom muaj txiaj ntsig zoo rau kev tsim kev ntseeg siab nrog lawv cov neeg siv khoom.
Pros
- Family-owned company
- Formulated nrog zoo proteins
- Qhia ntau yam qhuav thiab ntub dej
- Nyob rau cov dev ntawm txhua lub hnub nyoog thiab qhov ntau thiab tsawg
- Tshuaj nyob rau hauv tsev neeg muaj chaw
Cons
- Rau keeb kwm
- Nyuaj nrhiav hauv khw hauv online
- Kim
About Acana
Acana yog lub tuam txhab khoom noj tsiaj nrog lub hauv paus hauv Surrey, UK, tab sis nrog nws cov hauv paus hauv Alberta, Canada. Cov khoom noj Acana ua tau siav hauv Alberta hnub no, thiab tseem nyob hauv Edmonton thiab Auburn, Kentucky.
Tau ntau tshaj li ib feem peb ntawm ib puas xyoo, Acana tau tsim cov khoom noj tsiaj raws li lawv hu ua "txoj cai 5". Acana tus cwj pwm yog los tsim cov khoom noj uas yog tsim los ntawm cov khoom xyaw tshiab hauv cheeb tsam, cov nqaij zoo, thiab cov proteins, thiab qhov ntawd tsis yog tsim los ntawm peb tog-tsuas yog Acana nws tus kheej.
Pros
- Formulated nrog txog 75% tsiaj proteins
- Made in Canadian thiab US chav ua noj
- Tsis yog outsourced
- Tsis nco qab keeb kwm
- Easy to find online
Cons
- History of class-action lawsuits
- Kev xaiv zaub mov tsawg dua
3 Feem ntau Nroj Tsuag Los Ntawm Dog Zaub Zaub Recipes
Qhia rau koj paub tias muaj dab tsi, peb tau sib sau peb ntawm Fromm cov zaub mov nrov tshaj plaws. Mus saib lawv hauv qab no.
Disclaimer: Yog tias koj tab tom xav txog kev noj zaub mov tsis muaj nplej, peb xav kom koj tham nrog koj tus kws kho tsiaj vim nws yuav tsis yog qhov kev xaiv zoo tshaj rau koj tus dev. Tsis tas li ntawd, FDA tab tom tshawb xyuas qhov sib txuas ntawm cov legumes hauv cov zaub mov dev thiab cov teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv-tsuas yog ib yam uas yuav tsum tau paub txog.
1. Fromm Tsev Neeg Khoom Noj Cov Neeg Laus Kub
Daim ntawv qhia zaub mov no yog tsim los ntawm ntau yam nqaij nrog rau cov duck tshiab, nqaij qaib, thiab yaj. Lwm cov khoom xyaw muaj xws li cheese tiag tiag thiab tag nrho cov qe, thiab daim ntawv qhia yog infused nrog salmon roj los pab koj tus dev lub tsho tiv no thiab probiotics rau kev zom. Nws yog tsim los rau cov dev laus uas muaj kev ua haujlwm ib txwm muaj.
Cov Neeg Laus Kub cov zaub mov muaj protein ntau ntawm 25%. Nws muaj cov dej noo ntawm 10%, qib roj ntawm 16%, thiab 5.5% fiber ntau. Nws yog me ntsis pricey, nws yuav tsum tau hais, tab sis yog ib qho ntawm Fromm tus qauv thiab nrov tshaj plaws rau cov neeg laus dev.
Pros
- High hauv protein
- Muaj cov nqaij tshiab
- Contains adds probiotics and salmon oil
- Highly-reviewed
Cons
Kim
2. Fromm Tsev Neeg Khoom Noj Tsis Pub Dawb Heartland Kub
Lwm qhov kev xaiv Fromm nrov yog cov kab no tsis muaj nplej hu ua Heartland Gold. Daim ntawv qhia no yog ua nrog nqaij nyug, nqaij npuas, thiab yaj thiab, zoo li tus qauv kub kab, muaj probiotics thiab salmon roj. Lwm cov khoom xyaw muaj xws li legumes xws li chickpeas, lentils, thiab qos yaj ywm. Cov zaub mov no muaj 24% protein-me me qis dua tus qauv tus neeg laus kub xaiv-16% rog, 6.0% fiber ntau, thiab 10% ya raws.
Los ntawm cov ntawv sau tseg tias cov khoom no yog tsim los ua kom tau raws li cov kev xav tau ntawm cov dev loj hlob raws li AAFCO cov qauv, tshwj tsis yog cov dev loj dua 70 lbs, yog li yog tias koj tus dev nyob rau sab loj, koj yuav xav xav txog lwm qhov. kev xaiv.
Pros
- High hauv protein
- Muaj ntau yam nqaij
- Cov khoom xyaw zoo heev
- Contains probiotics and salmon oil
Cons
- Kim
- Tsis haum rau dev tshaj 70 lbs
3. Fromm Family Foods Nutritionals Qaib À La Veg Recipe
Rau cov phooj ywg furry uas txaus siab rau haute cuisine, Fromm muaj daim ntawv qhia nqaij qaib à la veg. Cov khoom no yog tsim nrog nqaij qaib, nqaij qaib broth, qos yaj ywm qab zib, thiab cov txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub-zoo nkauj los yog dab tsi?! Nws tau txais glowing xyuas los ntawm cov niam txiv dev uas tau tawm tswv yim tias lawv cov dev nyiam saj thiab pom nws yooj yim rau plab.
Daim ntawv qhia no yog tsim los ntawm 24% protein, 15% rog, 5.5% fiber ntau, thiab 10% ya raws. Nws kuj ua tau raws li AAFCO cov qauv kev noj haus rau txhua tus dev, suav nrog cov neeg tshaj 70 lbs.
Pros
- High hauv protein
- Zoo rau dev
- Haum rau txhua tus dev, suav nrog cov neeg siab dua 70 lbs
- Cov khoom xyaw zoo heev
Cons
Kim
3 Feem ntau nrov Acana Dog Food Recipes
Zoo li Fromm, Acana muaj ntau yam zoo nkauj ntawm cov zaub mov noj dev kom cov dev ntawm txhua daim duab thiab qhov ntau thiab tsawg zoo siab. Nov yog qee qhov kev xaiv nrov tshaj plaws los ntawm Acana ntau yam.
Disclaimer: Yog tias koj tab tom xav txog kev noj zaub mov tsis muaj nplej, peb xav kom koj tham nrog koj tus kws kho tsiaj vim nws yuav tsis yog qhov kev xaiv zoo tshaj rau koj tus dev. Tsis tas li ntawd, FDA tab tom tshawb xyuas qhov sib txuas ntawm cov legumes hauv cov zaub mov dev thiab cov teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv-tsuas yog ib yam uas yuav tsum tau paub txog.
1. Acana Red Meat Recipe (Grain-Free)
Disclaimer: Yog tias koj tab tom xav txog kev noj zaub mov tsis muaj nplej, peb xav kom koj tham nrog koj tus kws kho tsiaj vim nws yuav tsis yog qhov kev xaiv zoo tshaj rau koj tus dev. Tsis tas li ntawd, FDA tab tom tshawb xyuas qhov sib txuas ntawm cov legumes hauv cov zaub mov dev thiab cov teeb meem kev noj qab haus huv-tsuas yog ib yam uas yuav tsum tau paub txog.
Acana siv cov txheej txheem khov-drying txheej rau saj zoo tshaj plaws. Hauv qhov no, cov khoom noj yog coated hauv nqaij nyug, nqaij npuas, thiab yaj daim siab.
Pros
- 60% tsiaj-derived proteins
- Cov khoom xyaw tshiab
- Made in US kitchens
- Nkag-qhuav coated kom saj zoo dua
- No artificial flavorings
Cons
Kim
2. Acana Freshwater Ntses Recipe (Grain-Free)
Acana daim ntawv qhia nqaij liab yog ib qho khoom muag zoo tshaj plaws Acana. Nws muaj cov nqaij nyuj tshiab los yog nyoos thiab nqaij npuas, uas ua rau thawj ob qho khoom xyaw. Lwm cov khoom xyaw suav nrog cov txiv hmab txiv ntoo tshiab thiab zaub, thiab nws tsis muaj cov khoom xyaw. Daim ntawv qhia no yog tsim nyob rau hauv US chav ua noj thiab muaj 60% high-in-protein tsiaj-derived cov khoom xyaw. Cov qib protein crude yog 29%, cov rog cov ntsiab lus 17%, thiab cov ntsiab lus fiber ntau 5%
Lwm yam ntawm Acana cov khoom muag zoo tshaj plaws yog daim ntawv qhia ntses dej tshiab. Nws 60% cov protein tau los ntawm tsiaj los ntawm ntses ntses, perch, thiab zaj sawv trout thiab, zoo li nrog daim ntawv qhia nqaij liab, qhov no yog sib npaug los ntawm 40% txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub. Cov khoom ntses yog khov thaum lawv tshiab tshaj plaws kom khaws lawv cov khoom zoo thiab saj.
Pros
- Tub thiab ntses yog thawj ob qho khoom xyaw
- High hauv protein
- Made in US kitchens
- Nkag-qhuav coated kom saj zoo dua
- No artificial flavorings
Cons
Kim
3. Acana Highest Protein Wild Atlantic Recipe (Grain-Free)
Zoo li lwm yam khoom Acana, daim ntawv qhia no tsis muaj cov khoom xyaw. Nws qib protein yog 29%, rog rog yog 17%, thiab qib fiber ntau yog 6%. Nws tau txais kev sib xyaw tab sis kev tshuaj xyuas zoo heev. Txawm hais tias qee cov neeg siv tsis txaus siab rau cov khoom lag luam thiab hais tias nws tsis haum rau lawv cov dev, lwm tus tau qhuas tias nws tau txais txiaj ntsig zoo rau lawv cov dev, kev noj qab haus huv.
Cov qib protein crude yog 33%, nrog rau qib roj ntawm 17% thiab fiber ntau ntawm 6%. Kev tshuaj xyuas yog qhov zoo rau feem ntau, thiab txawm li cas los xij, qee tus tsis xav tias nws haum rau lawv tus dev, ntau tus tau qhuas tias lawv cov dev noj qab npaum li cas tau pom daim ntawv qhia no thiab nws tau txais txiaj ntsig zoo rau lawv txoj kev noj qab haus huv.
Pros
- Hloov muaj protein ntau
- Made in US kitchens
- Nyob zoo heev
- Supports noj qab nyob zoo digestion
Cons
Kim
Rau Keeb Kwm Ntawm Fromm thiab Acana
Lwm qhov kev tshuaj xyuas thiab kev xaiv nrov los ntawm Acana kab yog Daim Ntawv Qhia Siab Tshaj Plaws Zoo Tshaj Plaws Atlantic. Ua nrog mackerel, herring, thiab redfish uas, zoo li nrog rau lwm yam khoom Acana, yog khov tshiab, daim ntawv qhia no yog tsim los txhawb kev noj qab haus huv digestion nrog prebiotics thiab fiber. Qhov no yog cov protein ntau dua, nrog 70% protein tau los ntawm cov tsiaj txhu thiab 30% txiv hmab txiv ntoo thiab zaub.
Acana, ntawm qhov sib txawv, tsis muaj keeb kwm rov qab los. Txawm li cas los xij, ob qho tib si Fromm thiab Acana, nrog rau lwm lub npe uas muag cov khoom tsis muaj nplej, tau teev nyob rau hauv 2019 FDA daim ntawv tshaj tawm tias muaj peev xwm txuas rau kab mob plawv.
Fromm vs Acana Sib piv
Nyob rau xyoo 2016, peb yam khoom Fromm yog qhov raug xa rov qab los ntawm kev nce qib ntawm cov vitamin D. Ib tsab ntawv ceeb toom FDA hnub tim 1 Lub Kaum Hli, 2021, piav qhia tias Fromm tau tso cai rov qab los ntawm plaub yam khoom los ntawm Fromm Four- Lub hnub qub kab vim nce qib vitamin D. Raws li tsab ntawv ceeb toom, tsis muaj tus tswv dev tau tawm los hais tias lawv cov dev tau cuam tshuam.
Taste
Qhov no yog cov ntsiab lus thiab tiag tiag nyob ntawm koj tus dev nyiam. Qhov peb paub yog tias ob qho tib si Fromm thiab Acana siv ntau yam nqaij hauv lawv cov khoom, yog li muaj ntau ntau cov flavors xaiv los ntawm ob hom.
Nqaij qaib, nqaij nyuj, nqaij npuas, yaj, qaib ntxhw, thiab ntses yog siv los ntawm ob qho tib si Fromm thiab Acana, tab sis Acana zoo li siv ntau hom ntses dua Fromm. Ntawm qhov tod tes, Fromm zoo li muaj ntau "gourmet-style" kev xaiv ntawm kev muab.
Qhia tawm ntawm txoj kev, peb yuav rhuav tshem nws me ntsis ntxiv thiab tshawb xyuas seb txhua lub npe zoo li cas hauv cov ntsiab lus ntawm saj, zaub mov muaj nqis, nqe, xaiv cov zaub mov txawv, thiab tom qab ntawd tshaj tawm tus yeej. Nyeem rau kom paub ntau ntxiv txog peb qhov kev xaiv yeej thiab vim li cas peb thiaj xaiv nws rau qhov chaw saum toj kawg nkaus.
Nutritional Value
Ob qho tib si Acana thiab Fromm yog cov kev xaiv khoom noj khoom haus zoo, tab sis kom yooj yim cov teeb meem thiab pom qhov twg muaj ntug me ntsis, peb tau muab tso ua ke cov lus no raws li kev soj ntsuam kev noj haus ntawm peb ntawm txhua hom khoom nrov tshaj plaws..
| Product Name | Crude Protein | Crude Fat | Crude Fiber |
| Acana Red Meat Recipe | 29% | 17% | 6% |
| Acana Freshwater Fish Recipe | 29% | 17% | 6% |
| Acana Highest Protein Wild Atlantic Recipe | 33% | 17% | 6% |
| From Family Foods Adult Gold | 25% | 16% | 5.5% |
| From Family Foods Grain-Free Heartland Gold | 24% | 16% | 6.0% |
| Fromm Family Foods Four-Star Nutritionals Chicken À La Veg Recipe | 24% | 15% | 5.5% |
Raws li peb tuaj yeem pom los ntawm cov lus no, cov khoom lag luam Acana zoo li muaj cov protein ntau dua tag nrho, txawm tias tsis muaj ntau ntawm lawv cov ntsiab lus ntawm cov roj thiab fiber ntau. Vim tias cov ntsiab lus protein ntau dua hauv nws cov khoom, Acana zoo li yog cov khoom noj muaj txiaj ntsig tshaj plaws ntawm ob.
Price
Raws li ob qho tib si Acana thiab Fromm raug suav hais tias yog "khoom noj khoom haus zoo tshaj" hom khoom noj tsiaj, tsis tuaj yeem pheej yig tshwj xeeb, txawm tias qhov ua tau zoo rau qhov no. Tus nqi tag nrho tseem tuaj yeem nyob ntawm tus neeg muag khoom, vim tsis yog Acana lossis Fromm muag lawv cov khoom ntawm lawv tus kheej lub vev xaib.
Nyob rau hauv cov nqe lus ntawm cov neeg siv tshuaj xyuas, ob qho tib si Fromm thiab Acana tau raug qhuas rau ntau yam hauv flavors ntawm lawv cov khoom. Yog tias peb yuav tsum xaiv tus yeej rau qhov kev sib tw no, peb yuav tsum tau hu nws txoj hlua khi vim muaj ntau yam khoom qab zib ntawm kev muab thiab cov kev tshuaj xyuas zoo tau txais los ntawm ob lub npe hauv pawg no.
Selection
Figures-wise, Fromm cov khoom nruab nrab tawm ntawm kwv yees li $2.78 ib phaus, thaum Acana nruab nrab ntawm $3.54 ib phaus. Fromm nqi txog $0.0017 ib calorie thiab Acana, txog $0.0023 ib calorie. Yuav kom suav sau, nws yuav tshwm sim tias Fromm pheej yig dua li Acana, tab sis tsuas yog los ntawm plaub hau xwb.
Yog li, yog tias koj tab tom nrhiav kev noj zaub mov qhuav, koj tsis tuaj yeem ua tsis ncaj ncees rau ob hom, tab sis yog tias koj tus dev noj cov zaub mov ntub, koj yuav muaj ntau txoj kev xaiv los ntawm Fromm.
Txhua
Acana thiab Fromm zoo li muaj cov khoom noj qhuav zoo sib xws. Peb tau tshawb xyuas ob lub vev xaib raug cai thiab pom tias ob qho tib si muaj ntau yam rau cov menyuam dev, cov dev laus, thiab cov dev laus. Kuj muaj ntau yam kev kho mob. Fromm muaj ib tug me ntsis ntug nyob rau hauv ntau npaum li cas cov khoom nyob rau hauv kev muab vim hais tias nws muaj ib tug ntub zaub mov kab. Acana ua ib yam nkaus, tab sis muaj kev xaiv tsawg dua. Uas tau hais tias, vim hais tias ib kab muaj tsawg dua cov khoom tsis txhais hais tias nws qhov zoo raug cuam tshuam.
Txhua yam, peb xav tias muaj ntau yam nyiam txog ntawm Fromm thiab Acana. Fromm yog ib lub tuam txhab muaj tsev neeg uas muaj keeb kwm ntev ntawm kev tsim cov khoom noj dev ua los ntawm cov protein zoo kom haum rau ntau yam kev xav tau. Nws tseem muaj npe nrov rau kev tsim cov khoom noj "gourmet-style" thiab muaj ntau yam khoom noj ntub dej.
Conclusion
Acana yog ib lub tuam txhab hluas, tab sis peb nyiam tias 50% -75% ntawm nws cov khoom muaj pes tsawg leeg yog tsim los ntawm cov protein uas tau los ntawm cov nqaij zoo. Nws cov khoom kuj yog ib qho tad siab dua hauv cov protein nyob nruab nrab thiab siv tau ntau dua thaum yuav khoom hauv online. Nws kuj tsis muaj keeb kwm ntawm kev nco qab. Rau cov laj thawj no thiab raws li peb cov kev tshawb fawb, peb tau xaiv Acana ua peb nyiam ntawm ob.
Peb xav tias txawm tias koj mus rau Acana lossis Fromm, koj yuav tsis tuaj yeem mus deb ntawm qhov tsis ncaj ncees lawm-ob qho tib si tsim cov khoom noj dev zoo tshaj plaws thiab muaj ntau yam khoom siv los ua noj rau cov dev ntawm txhua lub hnub nyoog, cov duab, thiab qhov ntau thiab tsawg.
